The One About the Breakup.

Posted by on April 6, 2010

This is the blog post I didn’t want to write. I knew it needed to be written but there were so many reasons to not write it. You see, it is about a breakup, and as in most breakups there is more than one person involved, but unlike many there is also more than two. I cannot speak for the other parties I can only speak for how I was impacted and how I observed it impact someone I love dearly.

Early last year Jewelgen and I were sailing along in our journey of discovery of both Kink and Polyamory. We had a beautiful relationship developing with Ice Empress and had been enjoying playing together and separately with other partners. We had for sometime considered ourselves San Francisco kinksters even though we live 50 miles away. Most of the fun we could find was in SF, we had found a great munch there and we had never been able to connect with local folks.

Then we finally pushed ourselves to go to a local munch and immediately made connections. Some friends, some play partners. However there was one person in particular who stood out. She was a very shy submissive woman who identified as a single slave. I will call her Aliah but this is not her name. She was well known in the local community and had been involved in the kink world for many years.

Aliah first approached us about carpooling to a class in SF and a friendship between the three of us quickly developed. After a few months of the friendship blossoming, Aliah approached us with a very interesting proposal. She wanted us to consider allowing her to be “In Service” to us. WE asked her to explain what this would mean. She defined this as Slavery but in a format that would fit our busy lives and would not have the level of commitment on our part as collaring her as a slave. The idea appealed to us on several levels. First we are primarily parents and do not integrate our kinky or poly life into our children’s life, so a 24/7 situation was not possible.  Second even though we did not have a kinky or sexual attraction to her, her primary kink was service and the services she suggested were things that appealed to us.

We did have some concerns however. Aliah had mentioned on several occasions that she did not see her self as “poly” and her hope was to some day meet a Master who was Monogamous as well. We made it clear to her that not only were we very poly, and had no intention of changing that, but there was someone in our life that would come above anyone else, Ice Empress. I was also involved in a secondary relationship at the time. We explained clearly that if either of these things were unbearable at that point or in the future that she was free to walk away. She agreed.

Things started very well and her attentions were amazing. Aliah would chauffer us to munches and kinky events and look after our every need. She introduced us to friends who had long histories of leadership in the kink community and we became even closer. We shared trials and triumphs like you do with someone you care about and with whom you share a relationship. Troubles cropped up and we were very proud of how our communication skills lead to apparent resolutions. Unfortunately more often than not the problems centered on insecurities and jealousy, however we forged on.

In the meantime we became even closer to some of Aliah friends and one in particular with whom Aliah had a murky past, but with who she was “only friends”, grew close to Jewelgen. “Calvin” cared for Aliah deeply as a brother would but it was clear he had a very serious interest in Jewelgen and a great friendship was developing as well as a potential for some very hot play.

As the summer wore on we had several talks with Aliah regarding her behavior and jealousy and each time it seamed progress was made. It concerned me when I ended my secondary relationship and she seemed overjoyed but I let it go.

But as Fall approached two events occured that appeared to be Catalyst for bad behavior. Ice Empress came to visit us and our relationship with her gelled, and plans for Ice Empress moving here became solidified. This occurred during the Folsom Street fair which is an event that I for one look forward to all year. Aliah’s behavior at Folsom was intolerable and when we returned home and had our sad farewells with Ice Empress we let Aliah know. The second event was the consummation of the developing play relationship with Jewelgen and Calvin, which was also clearly a very good friendship in the making. The three of us – Jewelgen, Myself, and Calvin – had all spoken at length to Aliah about this and she had wholeheartedly encouraged it, at least in words and appearance. However her reaction after the day they first played made it clear that she was not “OK” with the situation.

Jewelgen and I started to realize that this situation with Aliah was most likely doomed but we wanted to give her another chance when suddenly Jewelgen and I were struck with a horrendous personal tragedy. We let Aliah know that we would be unavailable for some time and did not know when that would change but that we greatly appreciated her support. We stayed in semi-regular contact with her but had sequestered ourselves in our home. After several weeks when the situation had mostly resolved we contacted Aliah about spending some time together but the reception we received was cold. Jewelgen and I spoke and we knew that time had come to end our service relationship with Aliah. We asked her to meet us at a neutral location and it was obvious that she not only knew why we were meeting but that she desired an end as well.

After some conversation it was decided that we were friends to begin with and that an end had been called at a good time so it would be wonderful if we could still be friends.

We may have been naive but we truly hoped that we could continue to be friends with Aliah and move forward. A few weeks later we attended a play party hosted by f a friend of Aliah. We had received our invitation some time earlier and we had no reason to think we were not still welcome. We soon discovered otherwise. Our reception at the party was mostly very cold. It even appeared that Calvin was giving us the cold shoulder but we chalked it up to other things he was involved in that night.

The truth became evident quickly though. Invitations we had been promised to several play parties never materialized and Calvin snubbed not just me but quite hurtfully Jewelgen. That is not to say that al the local folks were rude, in fact we received much encouragement and support from many local folks, but the degree of snubbing from people we had come to regard as friends was shocking. The poor treatment of me caught me by surprise but the treatment of Jewelgen caught me with anger, the sort of white hot anger that few people have witnessed in me and escaped unscathed. However Jewelgen appealed to me to let it go, and I respected her wishes. I was angry at Aliah for what was clearly a campaign to malign us, but even more so I was angry at both Aliah and Calvin for hurting the one person in the world that meant the most to me, Jewelgen.

I have avoided writing this post for quite some time. I did not want to smear anyone and it seemed better to just sit on it. But it has grown like a boil and festered to the point that it has blocked my ability to write about anything else.

It is still not my intention to create animosity towards Aliah but to highlight something that we simply had not considered.  You see if this was simply a Vanilla relationship ending we could change things in our life so we could simply avoid the other party. However the Kink community is small and it is not possible to stay active while avoiding someone you shared something with. This did not occur to us at the beginning but I assure you we are well aware of now.

Spring has come and Jewelgen and I are emerging from our shell. We are making plans to become more active again and we revel in the excitement of Ice Empress’ arrival later in the year. We have learned some valuable lessons and I hope they have not jaded us too unnecessarily, but I can assure that we will look long and hard before inviting anyone besides the three of us to enter so closely into our lives again.

wordpress plugins and themes

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Comments (12)

  • Generally speaking, all too often when things go badly in a kink relationship, this is one of the types of things that happens. Often, one of the parties will withdraw from the scene temporarily in order to let the situation find a self-leveling point. You're correct that within such a small community, it's difficult to avoid people and still partake in the activities, classes, and parties that we all learn to enjoy. You appear to have a very strong relationship with Jewelgen and Ice Empress and seem to anchor each other very well. Kudos on holding your head high and realizing that sometimes you just have to get things off your chest in order to move on.

  • Yikes, that really sucks. It always seems that breakups amongst kinky people, even if it's a nonsexual kink like service, are ten times worse than “regular” breakups, for a number of reasons. I'm really sorry it had to happen on such an ugly scale to both you and Jewelgen. I'm glad, though, that you're both moving on and not letting it affect you much in the long run. You are both better than all of that shit. Hugs to both of you!

  • It sounds like you would have quite a bit to post on Kink Relationships and how to get back into the scene once a relationship ends as it appears you did nothing wrong in this instance. In my opinion it is easier if you don't avoid people you have broken up with especially since the kink scene is so small.

  • I'm not sure why you found it necessary to air your dirty laundry and whine about not being invited to parties. Seems to me that the honorable thing would be to let it go and move on with your life without all the fanfare. Obviously you are new to the scene and have much to learn about how communities work. As someone who's been around for awhile, I think I can safely say that your behavior has caused you more harm than good. What you forgot to tell in your blog was the complete story. No one is ever completely blameless, especially one who yells the loudest. It is usually that person who has the most to conceal. Shame on you!
    The bridge has been burned and now it's time for you to get out your tools and start with the repairs.

    • Saynine seems like he thought this out. He really has been sitting on this a while and mentions why it is hard to talk about. Usually one so quick to call it quits (rather than make an effort to see if compromise can be reached) and write about it when emotions are still high (and the blood from the wounds still fresh) are the ones that are more likely to step into manure

      This is less about Saynine being butthurt about the lack of party invites. While people local and in the scene were encouraging them, people that Saynine deemed close friends suddenly did a 180 on them. If they were people they didnt know, I could easily say it was a sign of butthurt. However, people that you ARE SUPPOSED to be close to snubbing and reneging invites without really any desire to discus things first….thats just rude and I think they have every right to be hurt over it.

      I will simply have to agree to disagree here. Saynine did NOT mention names. He used substitute names so that no one was getting called out. In this situation, the only way anyone would know whom he is speaking of is if they knew him really well (like Jewelgen) or the person this is about commented here and alluded to this being about her (like if she wanted to get on here and call him out). With names removed/changed and no deep delving into anal retentive details of the events, this entry leaves us with the situation and story which overall is the most important.

      Intention is everything.

  • That was sad dude. Sighs I worry about the same thing occurring. Right now My wife and I are seeing a “friend” together. Things will probably be ending soon, at least on our friend and my part. She wants something more casual, I am not going to be able to handle that. I hope that their aren't any repercussions, and I hope my wife and she can continue their play and friendship.

  • This similar situation happens around here within the swinging circles. It *almost* happened to Love and I but it was quickly averted before anything intimate had a chance to occur, mostly because we heard the rumblings in time from others peripherally involved, they'd experienced the same type of drama with the same people who were trying to play with us. We completely stepped down from the scene which we likely shouldn't have because its hella hard to get back on that horse sometimes, but we also learned much in the process. We're avoiding that particular group from now on, but as you've said: the community is small, and I'd imagine much smaller when it comes to full on kink. Its really hard to move on, and sometimes it gets really messy as well..

    As for the commentor who believes that you didn't tell the entire story: Well maybe not, but that isn't necessary really, this blog is YOUR journey and YOUR feelings/experiences. Nobody ever said you need to analyze the experiences and emotions of every single person you come into contact with, we (or at least I) read your words because I care about YOU and what YOU are feeling.

    A wise man (my beloved father, RIP) once told me that there are always three sides to any/every story anyway: His, Hers, and The Truth. Nobody can ever know any of those 100% even if they were there and its impossible to reconcile all three at all so maybe we'll just continue to share in YOUR words as you grow and share what bits of your journey that you can because for some of us: Its enlightening and inspirational and oftentimes quite entertaining: good, bad and ugly.

    Thank you.

  • thank you to those who had support to give. I guess I missed the disclaimer on here that says “On this blog the complete story, that is admissible in a court of law, will be told” That is how blogs work, I think grrltragic said it best.

    Gosh,with the support and adult behavior I will rush out and get to work trying to be friends with people who only pretend to kind to you, who only seek one side of the story, who attack and call it all in “good fun”. Yup, that is just what I need in my life….wait…. not really.

    It saddens me to see what get joy some are getting out of bashing.

    PS: this is all simply how I feel….assuming it is still allowed to voice how one feels in America.

  • Writing about a break-up is difficult, and can be problematic, especially when your intent is not to call anyone out or malign anyone, but simply share your thoughts & feelings on it. I sat on my own break-up for 3 months before even alluding to it in my own blog, but finally, like you, I NEEDED to write about it, for ME. Because blogging, in the end (for me) IS about me–my experiences, my feelings, my thoughts. I use it to process as much as share, and I couldn't not talk about it.

    But, as the comment from one of your readers shows, talking about it publicly has its own dangers. I disagree with him that you should have not written about it. If you feel the need to write about it, it's yours to write about. Yes, there is another side to things, but you can only write about what you know, and have no obligation to try to conjecture about the rest, or even to say anything else–this is YOUR space, no one else's. And it was pretty obvious to me (who has no real-life connection with you or the ppl involved) that you weren't “whining” about party invitations. As you say, the kink community is small, being subjected to rejection by those in it, ppl you called friend in the past, hurts.

    I wish you and Jewelgen well.

  • What you've described sounds painful but you're both obviously determined to grow from it. Good for you, and good luck in the future.

  • Saynine,
    It is unfortunate to experience an outcast of sorts; however, what I have learned through my short 37 years is that we truly never leave “high school” regardless of kinky or not. The people we were in high school, in elementary school tend to stay with us and as many know, segregating and snubbing people are age old behaviours. I do hope that doors will open again and you will be welcomed like you were before.

    Every relationship is individual and I know that many people do not understand what me and Master have and the people we involve and so I will not assume to understand everything that goes on and has been arranged/agreed upon for you and Jewelgen; however, I confess when I read about “Calvin” I could not help but think of all those pacts I have made with friends that involve not dating, not having sex, not being intimate with anyone any of them have liked, currently like or any other intimate feelings. Although Aliah stated she was okay, my first instinct is “no she is not”. Perhaps it is woman's intuition, perhaps it is from past experience, it just seemed careless on both of your parts to go further with any intimacy with Calvin. With that said, not my relationship, not my experience, I was not there and you all did what you believed was right, unfortunately it did not turn out as lovely as everyone hoped.

    I do hope that you are able to resurface in your kink community and embrace others and be embraced.

    Wishing you well.
    ~His

  • They say 'breaking up is hard to do'… and your situation is no different.
    I had a similar experience with a… let's call her a sub… with a vindictive streak a mile wide that couldn't handle the arrangement as intended… led to some interesting rumours flying around and my walking away from a number of people I had considered 'decent people'… only to realize their true natures in a time of strife.
    I didn't need that (or them) and neither do you.
    Good to hear that the two of you are back on the proverbial horse – as you said the community is small. I'd almost suggest for you to reacquaint yourselves with those in the community that you had connection with previous to the whole Aliah incident. Not to renegotiate any relationships (bridges tend to stay burned – regardless of who sets fire to them) but simply to suss out the issues and to demonstrate a sense of 'moving forward'… the more normal you appear through this whole silly ordeal, the less stigma gets heaped onto you and Jewel.
    Sadly, as HisTurtle posted previously, it's high school all over again. Emotionally charged neuroticism at its finest.

Do you have anything to say?

Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wpburn.com wordpress themes
Powered by Wordpress and Stripes Theme Entries (RSS) | Comments (RSS)